Well, I finally remembered, and now I have evidence to support my claim. Please behold:
Yes, I think my boyfriend looks like Wayne Gretzky - only the most famous hockey player in the entire world. And I swear on all my Harry Potter books that my enjoyment of hockey has no bearing on my adoration of Mark. I was never even a huge fan of Wayne's, although I certainly admired his skill.
So, what say you? Am I out of my gourd or is there a resemblance?